Judge the Work, Not the Quill
AI detection tools invite a scan-and-shame ritual. A score appears: human, AI-assisted, or AI. Readers treat it as a ruling on the value of the writing. The tool itself makes no such claim. It examines patterns of syntax and word choice, not whether the words are worth reading.
This is an old error in a new form. Process-focused attacks were once aimed at Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address and at the sources of Martin Luther King Jr.’s most famous speech. The tallies changed nothing. The words survived. The same arithmetic is now being applied to newsletters and essays.
